The 1938 “Long Island Express” Hurricane

While researching my novel, “Amanda’s Room,” I pondered the question, “What would it be like forNew Englandto be threatened with a late-season category-five hurricane?” That led to my studying the history of hurricanes inNew England, and that, in turn, led me to “The Long Island Express.”

Several major hurricanes have hitNew England, although not with the frequency or intensity of storms impacting other areas like the Gulf region or southeastern seaboard.

The Great Colonial Hurricane of 1635 was possibly the most powerful in recorded history, although the sparse population of the impacted areas limited casualties and the lack of sophisticated instrumentation at the time make it difficult to determine the full extent of the storm’s power.

The Great September Gale of 1815  hitNew York as a category 3 storm and separatedNew York’s Rockaways andLong Beach into two separate barrier islands.

The 1821 Norfolk and Long Island Hurricane created a storm surge inManhattan of nearly 13 feet, the highest ever recorded for the area.

The 1869 Saxby Gale did extensive damage toMaine’s coastline and the Canadian Outer Banks.

And the 1893 New York hurricane eradicated the Long Island Town ofHogIsland. However, in terms of raw power combined with total damage and loss of life, many regard the hurricane of 1938, commonly referred to as “The Long Island Express,” as the granddaddy of allNew England hurricanes.

On September 10, 1938, the storm started out meekly off the coast ofAfrica. As it moved westward, fueled by the warm, moist air over the mid-Atlantic, the storm grew in intensity. Ten days later, still east of theBahamas, it reached what today would be rated as a category 5 strength. At this point, the hurricane’s behavior shifted from the norm. Most storms either made landfall somewhere along the southeastern to mid-Atlantic coast, or tracked northeasterly and veered harmlessly out to sea again. But a deep trough over Appalachia, combined with a high-pressure system centered north ofBermuda, channeled the hurricane directly northward.

Most experts at the time believed the storm would eventually assume a more traditional trajectory, so the forecast forNew Englandcalled for cloudy skies and wind gusts, but not for hurricane conditions. Another unforeseen condition was that as the hurricane made its way up the coast, it picked up speed. Hurricanes in the northern hemisphere rotate in a counter-clockwise direction so the forward speed of the storm increases the speed of the winds on its eastern side relative to the land it passes over. At one time, that forward speed reached 70 miles per hour, the highest ever recorded for any hurricane. As the storm passedVirginia, its forward speed was still over 50 miles per hour. Shortly after 3:00 p.m. on September 21, 1938, the hurricane’s eye made landfall in Bayport and quickly traversedLong Island. Then it crossed Long Island Sound and made landfall again about 4:00 p.m. inNew Haven,Connecticut. The maximum winds speed has been analyzed to have been between 120 and 125 miles per hour, what today would be classified as a class 3 hurricane. The storms forward speed propelled it intoMassachusettsby 5:00 p.m. and then intoVermontby 6:00. Even more damaging than the high winds was the devastation caused by the storm surge. The effects of the Autumnal Equinox and a full moon exacerbated the surge. 

The hurricane produced storm tides of 14 to 18 feet across most of Long Island and theConnecticutcoast. New LondontoCape Codsaw tides of 18 to 25 feet. The water swept hundreds of summer cottages inRhode Islandout to sea and the entire community of Napatree Point, which housed some 40 families near Watch Hill, was obliterated. The storm killed over 650 to as many as 800 people and estimates of the storm damages totaled $306 million dollars. Accounting for inflation since then, that would equate to more than $41 billion dollars in 2012.

If all of this was caused by a category 3 storm, what kind of damage could a category 5 hurricane do toNew England? Perhaps this conversation between Bert Myers and Josh Gibbons, two fictitious characters from my novel, could serve to illustrate.

“So what do you think, Bert?” asked Josh. “I’m just a lowly mathematician. You’re the weather expert. Does it really look like we’re going to have front row seats to Armageddon?”

“I don’t know, Josh. NewEngland’s never been hit by a class five hurricane. The nearest we’ve come was the Long Island Express in 1938, and that was a class three. It decimated the coastline, flooded towns thirty miles inland, and created the Shinnecock Inlet.”

“Thanks for the real estate report. Not that I don’t appreciate hearing how the storm affected property values, but how about the really juicy numbers. How many died?”

“Over 700.”

“And that was a class three?”

Bert took another sip of his coffee. “Tornado hunters have an expression for an F-5 tornado. They call it the ‘Finger of God.’ A hurricane the size of Amanda could spin off a dozen that size. If an F-5 tornado is God’s finger, then in a few hours we’re going to get a firsthand look at His fist.”


Chuck Miceli

Author, Amanda’s Room


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s